ULUSLARARASI UYUÞMAZLIK ÇÖZÜMÜNDE USUL, UYGULAMALAR ve GÜNCEL SORUNLAR INTERNATIONAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION: PRACTICE, PROCEDURE and PROBLEMS Ankara, Türkiye 9 Ocak 2009 09.30-17.15 10 Ocak 2009 09.30-13.00 Ankara, Turkey 9 January 2009 09.30-17.15 10 January 2009 09.30-13.00 Konferans : Türkiye Barolar Birliði Ankara Barosu IDR Group Ýþbirliði ile düzenlenmiþtir. Yer: Crowne Plaza Hotel, Akköprü Migros Yaný Ankara Conference organized by: The Union of Turkish Bar Associations The Ankara Bar Association The IDR GROUP Venue: Crowne Plaza Hotel, Next to Akkopru Ankamall Ankara

9 Ocak : 1. GÜN 9.00-9.30 Kayýt 9.30-9.45 Açýlýþ Konuþmasý Özdemir Özok (Türkiye Barolar Birliði Baþkaný, Avukat) 9.45-10.00 Konferans Tanýtýmý Anthony Connerty, IDR Group 1. Oturum Baþkaný: Vedat Ahsen Coþar (Ankara Barosu Baþkaný, Avukat) 10.00-11.45 1. Oturum Uluslararasý Ticari Uyuþmalýk Çözümü: Uluslararasý Ticari Tahkim Kurumlarý; Ad Hoc Tahkimi ve Tahkimin Geleceði. Giovanni de Berti "Milan Tahkim Merkezi Akdeniz Projesi; Akdenize Kýyýsý Olan Ülkeler Arasý Köprü Kurulmasý" Anthony Connerty "Türk Taraflarýn Katýldýðý Örnekleri de Ýçeren Uygulamanýn Iþýðýnda Kurumsal ve Ad Hoc Tahkim" 11.45-12.15 Kahve Arasý 2. Oturum Baþkaný: Seçkin Arýkan (Ankara Barosu ADR Merkezi Baþkaný, Avukat) 12.15-13.15 2. Oturum Devletlerin Uluslararasý Uyuþmazlýka Bakýþý ve Lex Mercatoria 'nýn rolü. Reza Mohtashami "Ortadoðu Devletlerin Uluslararasý Mahkemelere Karþý Tutumu ve Geliþmeler; Birleþik Arap Emirlikleri ve Dubai örneði" Profesör Dr. Arzu Oðuz "Lex Mercatoria'nýn Uluslararasý Uyuþmazlýklardaki Rolü" 3. Oturum Baþkaný: Prof. Dr. Turgut Kalpsüz 14.45-15.45 3. Oturum Ýnþaat Endüstrisinde Uyuþmazlýk Çözümü John Tackaberry QC "Uluslararasý Ýnþaat Sözleþmelerinde Uyuþmazlýk Çözümü" Prof Dr. Ziya Akýncý "FIDIC Sözleþmeleri Uyarýnca Ýnþaat Uyuþmazlýklarýnýn Çözümü" 15.45-16.15 Kahve Arasý 4. Oturum Baþkaný: Musa Toprak (Türkiye Barolar Birliði, Avukat) 16.15-17.15 4. Oturum Enerji Hukukunda Uyuþmazlýklar Profesör Munir Manurizzaman "Petrol ve Gaz Endüstrisinde Uyuþmazlýklar ve Doðal Kaynaklar" Profesör Dr. Ali Ulusoy "Türk Enerji Hukukunda Lisans Rejimi Üzerine Düþünceler"

9 January : DAY 1 9.00-9.30 Registration 9.30-9.45 Welcome Address Özdemir Özok (Attorney at Law, President of the Union of Turkish Bar Associations) 9.45-10.00 Conference Overview Anthony Connerty, IDR Group Chairperson of Session 1: Vedat Ahsen Coþar (Attorney at Law, President of the Ankara Bar Association) 10.00-11.45 Session 1 International Commercial Dispute Resolution: The international commercial arbitral institutions; ad hoc arbitration Giovanni de Berti "The Mediterranean Project of the Milan Chamber of Arbitration: a bridge across the shores of the Mediterranean Basin." Anthony Connerty "Institutional and ad hoc arbitration - and examples of international ad hoc arbitrations involving Turkish Parties." 11.45-12.15 Coffee Break Chairperson of Session 2: Seçkin Arýkan (President of Ankara Bar Association ADR Center, Attorney at law) 12.15-13.15 Session 2 Inter-State Dispute Resolution - and the role of Lex Mercatoria Reza Mohtashami "The position of Middle East governments against international tribunals and the future prospects, Dubai and UAE case" Professor Arzu Oðuz "The role of Lex Mercatoria in international disputes." Chairperson of Session 3: Professor Turgut Kalpsüz 14.45-15.45 Session 3 Dispute Resolution in the Construction Industry John Tackaberry QC "International Construction Contract Dispute Resolution" Professor Ziya Akýncý "Construction Disputes under FIDIC Contracts" 15.45-16.15 Coffee Break Chairperson of Session 4: Musa Toprak (Union of Turkish Bar Associations, Attorney at Law) 16.15-17.15 Session 4 Dispute Resolution in Energy Law Professor Munir Manurizzaman "Dispute Resolution in the Oil and Gas Industry - and the issue of Resource Nationalism" Professor Ali UIusoy "Energy Licence Regime in Turkey"

10 Ocak : 2. GÜN 5. Oturum Baþkaný: Özcan Çine (Türkiye Barolar Birliði Hukuk Ýþleri Müdürü, Avukat) 9.30-10.30 5. Oturum Yabancý Unsurlu Kararlarýn Uygulanabilirliði Profesör Guido Carducci "Newyork ve ICSID Konvansiyonuna Göre Uluslararasý Tahkim Kararlarý" Serhat Eskiyörük "Devletler ve Devlet Kuruluþlarý Aleyhine Verilen Kararlarýn Ýnfazý" 10.30-11.00 Kahve Arasý 6. Oturum Baþkaný: Þamil Demir (Alternatif Uyuþmazlýk Çözümleri Derneði Baþkan Yardýmcýsý, Ankara Barosu ADR Merkezi Yürütme Kurulu Üyesi, Avukat) 11.00-12.00 6. Oturum Türkiye'de Tahkim ve ADR Profesör Dr. Cemal Þanlý "Türkiye'de Tahkim Uygulamasý ve Prosedürü" Yard. Doç. Dr. Mustafa Özbek "Yeni Arabuluculuk Yasa Tasarýsýný ile birlikte Uyuþmazlýk Çözümünün Türkiye'deki Geleceði" 12.00-13.00 Kapanýþ Konuþmalarý Vedat Ahsen Coþar (Ankara Barosu Baþkaný, Avukat) Anthony Connerty (IDR Group) Konferans Kapanýþý IDR GROUP HAKKINDA IDR GROUP Uluslararasý uyuþmazlýk çözümü uzmanlarýndan oluþan bir gruptur. Grup üyeleri, birçok ülkeden avukatlar, hakemler ve diðer profesyonellerden oluþmaktadýr. Grup üyeleri Devletlerlerin taraf olduðu Uluslararasý Adalet Divaný, Lahey Daimi Tahkim Mahkemesi, Uluslararasý Deniz Mahkemeleri gibi kurumlarda Hakimlik, Tahkim Hakemliði, Avukatlýk görevlerinde bulunmuþtur. IDR Group kar amacý gütmeyen bir organizasyondur. Grubun baþkanlýðýný Anthony Connerty yapmaktadýr. www.idrgroup.org

10 January: DAY 2 Chairperson of Session 5 Özcan Çine (Union of Turkish Bar Associations, Head of Legal Department, Attorney at Law) 9.30-10.30 Session 5 The Enforcement of Awards Profesör Guido Carducci "International Arbitral Awards under the New York and ICSID Conventions" Serhat Eskiyörük "The Execution of Awards against States and State Entities" 10.30-11.00 Coffee Break Chairperson of Session 6: Þamil Demir (Vice President of Ankara ADR Association, Member of Ankara Bar ADR Center) 11.00-12.00 Session 6 Arbitration and ADR in Turkey Professor Cemal Þanlý "Arbitration practice and procedure in Turkey" Dr. Mustafa Özbek "The future of dispute resolution in Turkey following the new Mediation Act" 12.00-13.00 Closing Remarks Vedat Ahsen Coþar (Attorney at Law, President of the Ankara Bar Association) Anthony Connerty (IDR Group) Closing of the conference About the IDR Group THE IDR GROUP is a small group of international dispute resolution specialists. The Group was launched in April 2008 at a Reception in the Houses of Parliament. The membership of the Group is made up of arbitrators, lawyers and other professionals from a number of countries around the world. The experience of the Group reaches into the State level of international dispute resolution - various members have sat as Judges and Arbitrators in the International Court of Justice and the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague, and in the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea in Hamburg. Within the Group is a Panel of Consultants: experts in fields relevant to international dispute resolution such as petroleum, mining, metals and international affairs. The head of the Group is Anthony Connerty idrgroup.org

Yabancý Konuklarýmýz Hakkýnda Giovanni de Berti Ýtalya Barosu ve Gray's Inn, Ýngiltere Barosu, Ýtalya ve Ýngiltere Barolarýna kayýtlý avukat. Tahkim Kurumu (CIARB) Arabuluculuk Komisyon Baþkaný görevleri dýþýnda; Milan ve Hong Kong Tahkim Enstitülerinde çeþitli görevlerde bulunmaktadýr. Milan merkezli De Berti Jacchia hukuk þirketinin kurucu üyesi olup, tahkim ve arabuluculuk konularýnda geniþ bilgi ve deneyime sahiptir. Anthony Connerty IDR Group baþkaný, Ýngiltere Barosuna kayýtlý avukat (barrister) ve çeþitli enstitüler tahkim hakemi. Tahkim Kurumu (CIARB) Londra Yönetim Kurul üyesidir. Birleþik Krallýk Mahkemeleri tarafýndan atanmak suretiyle Londra Arabuluculuk Kurumu' nun kurulmasýný gerçekleþtirmiþtir. Ýngiltere, Avrupa, Afrika, Ortadoðu ve Çin de tahkim ve arabuluculuk konularýnda çeþitli konferanslar vermiþtir ve Abu Dabi, Kahire, Çin, Hong Kong, New York Nijerya, WIPO vs uluslararasý hukuk kurumlarý üyesidir. Ayrýca Manual of International Dispute Resolution kitabýnýn yazarýdýr. John Tackaberry Birleþik Krallýk Kraliyet Hukuk Danýþmaný, Avukat ve Hakem. Queensland University of Technology de Ýnþaat Hukuku ziyaretçi Profesörlüðü dýþýnda yine Ýngiltere, Kaliforniya, Hong Kong ve Malezya Barolarýna kayýtlý avukatlýk yapmaktadýr. Ayrýca, Birleþmiþ Milletler Tazmin Komisyonu eski üyeliði, CIARB Tahkim Kurumu eski Baþkaný, Ýnþaat Hukuku Kurulu kurucu baþkanlýðý ve Avrupa Ýnþaat Hukuku Kurumu eski baþkanlýðý görevlerinde bulunmuþtur. Yine ünlü "Handbook of Arbitration Practice" kitabinin da editörüdür. Profesör Munir Manurizzaman Enerji, Petrol ve Dogal Kaynaklar Hukuku Merkezi (CEPMLP) Dundee Üniversitesi ve Portsmouth Üniversitesi. Enerji, Petrol ve Doðal Kaynaklar Merkezi'nden, çeþitli ülke Üniversitelerde Profesörlük yapan, Londra, Paris, Strazburg, Teksas vs Tahkim Kurumlarý üyesi, Bangladeþ Baþkanýnýn Dýþiþleri Danýþmanlýðý görevlerinde bulunmuþ ve enerji hukuku uzmanýdýr. Uluslararasý Ticaret Odasý Dünya Ticaret Hukuku Komisyon üyesi olup, OGEL Asya Enerji Hukuku ve TDM Asya Uyuþmazlýk Çözümü, Oil, Gas and Energy Law Intelligence (OGEL), Transnational Dispute Management (TDM) ve benzeri hukuk yayýmlarýn editörlüðü görevlerinde bulunmaktadýr. Ýngiltere Portsmouth Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Araþtýrmalar Bölüm Baþkanlýðý dýþýnda Londra Üniversitesi Queen Mary, Kanada Western Ontario, Oxford ve Cambridge Üniversitelerinde profesörlük görevlerinde bulunmuþtur. Profesör Guido Carducci UNESCO Uluslararasý Standartlar Bölümü eski Baþkaný Guýdo Carduccý Pariste Hukuk Profesörlüðü yapmaktadýr. Roma ve Paris Barolarýna kayýtlý avukatlýk dýþýnda, ICC baþta olmak üzere çeþitli tahkim enstitülerde tahkim hakemi görevlerinde bulunmuþtur. Reza Mohtashami Reza Mohtashami Ýngiltere Barosuna kayýtlý olarak avukatlýk ve Freshfields Uluslararasý Tahkim Departmaný Ortadoðu sorumlusu olarak görev yapmaktadýr.yatýrým, enerji ve telekom uyuþmazlýklarý üzerine uzmanlaþmýþtýr. "ICSID - Procedural Issues" kitabý dahil olmak üzere bu konularda çeþitli eserleri bulunmaktadýr. Yine "Global Arbitration Review" editör yardýmcýlýðý ve Dubai Uluslararasý Finans Merkezi'ne Tahkim Kanunu deðiþikliði hususunda danýþmanlýk hizmetlerinde bulunmaktadýr

About Our Foreign Guests Giovanni de Berti Giovanni de Berti is a member of the Italian Bar and was called to the English Bar. He is a founding partner of the De Berti Jacchia law firm in Milan. Attorney, party - appointed arbitrator, sole arbitrator and Chairperson of arbitrations tribunals in various parts of the world. Attorney and mediator in institutional and ad hoc mediations. Anthony Connerty Head of IDR Group. Anthony Connerty is a Barrister in practice in London. He has acted as Advocate and Arbitrator in major international commercial arbitrations in multi-million U.S. dollar claims: in the UK, the US and China under the Rules of the ICC, LCIA, AAA/ICDR, LME and ad hoc (including arbitration under the UNCITRAL Rules). He has sat as arbitrator in international arbitrations involving Turkish parties. He has acted as Advocate and Mediator in international mediations in the UK, China and Singapore. John Tackaberry Barrister in practice in London, has extensive experience in building and civil engineering work; energy and natural resources; joint ventures; consortia cooperation; commercial arbitration; commercial shipping; commodity and international arbitration. He has expertise in international disputes throughout Europe, the USA, the West Indies, Africa, Hong Kong, Singapore, Malaysia, India and South America. He is heavily involved in ICC arbitrations. Professor Munir Manurizzaman Professor of International and Business Law, University of Portsmouth. Honorary Fellow, Centre for Energy, Petroleum and Mineral Law and Policy (CEPMLP), University of Dundee, Scotland. He has worked as an international arbitration law expert / consultant in high-profile ICSID and ICC cases, and as an International Legal Consultant to governments, state-owned enterprises, multinational corporations and multinational law firms. Professor Guido Carducci Guido Carducci is a Law Professor in Paris. He is a member of the Rome and Paris Bars. International Arbitrator in ICC and ad hoc arbitration proceedings. He is an Arbitrator and Conciliator on World Bank ICSID Panels for the Italian government. Former Chief of the International Standards Section of UNESCO. Reza Mohtashami Reza Mohtashami is a qualified solicitor of the Supreme Court of England and Wales and is admitted before the courts of the DIFC. He is counsel in Freshfields international arbitration group in Paris and Dubai offices. He specialises in investment treaty arbitration and disputes in the energy and telecoms industries. He has published several articles on international arbitration, including a handbook on ICSID - Procedural Issues. He is also a member of the editorial board of the Global Arbitration Review and a member of the working group advising the Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC) on the amendment of its arbitration law.

TÜRKÝYE BAROLAR BÝRLÝÐÝ Barýþ Manço Caddesi 1366. Sokak No: 3 06520 Balgat / Ankara Tel: (+90.312) 292 59 00 (Pbx) Faks: (+90.312) 286 55 65 web: www.barobirlik.org.tr e-posta: www.barobirlik.org.tr/iletisim